Product Review: Goodie Girl Birthday Cake Cookies

Our Junior Editor Viva was sold on these gluten free vanilla sandwich cookies just by looking at the box. “Birthday Cake” cookies? Sprinkles? It’s like a party in a box. At the checkout stand, our clerk told us he’s not even GF and doesn’t love cookies, yet he ate 10 in one sitting. So, are they ALL THAT? Let’s break it down.

First, we’ll start with the look: unlike the photo on the box, you won’t see lots of colorful sprinkles in the filling. You may see one or two muted stripes of color. But that’s beside the point. It’s the taste that matters, and these cookies are pretty darned good. The cookie is crisp, but not too dry (which can be the case with GF sandwich cookies), and it’s not overly sweet. The filling is very sweet, however. (A plus for our junior editor but a little less so for my grown up editor-in-chief palate). Still, as the clerk suggested, they are very easy going down, so even though I prefer chocolate sandwich cookies over vanilla, I ate a good handful of them, and quite happily.


INGREDIENTS: Sugar, vegetable shortening [soybean oil, monoglycerides, tocopherols (antioxidant), ascorbic palmitate (antioxidant), gluten free oat flour, rice flour, cornstarch, rainbow sprinkles (sugar, palm kernel and palm oil, cornstarch, vegetable juice, sunflower lecithin, annatto extract, spiraling extract, turmeric, beta-carotene, paprika oleoresin, maltodextrin, carnauba wax, cellulose gum), tapioca starch, invert syrup, contains 2% or less of: potato starch, soy lecithin, sodium bicorbonate, natural flavor, maltodextrin, gum arabic, xxanthan gum, salt nonfat milk, ammonium bicarbonate



OTHER HELPFUL INFORMATION: Kosher dairy. No peanuts. Contain no artificial flavors or ingredients. Produced in a facility that uses tree nuts.


NOTE: We only recommend products that we truly LOVE, use, and are confident to recommend. Thanks to affiliate partnership opportunities, we sometimes earn a small commission if you make a purchase through a product link on our site at no cost to you. But this has no influence on what we recommend. When we do score a few shekels, know that your purchase helps support our work to bring you trustworthy, unbiased information on an amazing gluten-free food and lifestyle.

5 Comments on “Product Review: Goodie Girl Birthday Cake Cookies”

  1. I haven’t tried the birthday cake cookies, but I love the Goodie Girl chocolate sandwich cookies. They look and taste like a famous brand of cookie. Their chocolate mint cookies and chocolate stripe cookies also taste like famous cookies that many people would recognize.

  2. Hello, Greysma! I know those famous cookies you mention and totally agree. Goodie Girl makes some GF fantastic cookies (and some I like a bit less).

  3. These cookies are really good! I have found them at Von’s and Walmart Superstores!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.